Cross-Examined for Hours, Juarez Still Says "I Bribed Mayor Sheng Thao"
Defense lawyers spent a day attacking the key witness in the federal bribery trial of ex-Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao. He admits his own record and still says he bribed her.
Sheng Thao — Former Mayor of Oakland, California (Oakland, California (federal court))
charged; federal trial underwayFollow-upto earlier pieces: Sheng Thao's Price List: A No-Show Job, a Salary Cap, a Bonus Per Unit (October 20, 2026); In the Sheng Thao Trial, the Star Witness Says She Wanted $300,000 (November 3, 2026)
Federal prosecutors say former Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao used her political power in exchange for business favors and money for her partner, and she is on trial. [S3][S2] The man who says he paid her spent hours under cross-examination and still says he bribed her. [S2][S3]
This site covered Thao on October 20, 2026 and again on November 3, 2026. What is new is the defense's attempt to dismantle the government's central witness, Mario Juarez. [S3]
The Case Against Sheng Thao
Juarez has pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit bribery of a public official. [S1] His plea agreement requires him to tell the truth on the stand, and he is hoping for a lighter sentence. [S1] He took the deal in exchange for testifying against Thao, her longtime partner Andre Jones, businessman Andy Duong and his father David Duong. [S2]
Federal prosecutors claim the Duongs conspired with Thao and Jones to use her political power in exchange for business favors and money for Jones. [S3] The Duong family owns California Waste Solutions, Oakland's recycling contractor. [S2]
The scheme at the center of the cross-examination involved efforts to persuade Oakland to buy container homes for homeless residents from Evolutionary Homes. [S1] According to testimony, that proposal involved up to $3 million in cash payments and commissions to Thao and her boyfriend. [S1]
The defense went after Juarez's record, and he conceded a lot of it.
- He acknowledged keeping about $200,000 of the $750,000 the Duongs provided to launch the company. [S1]
- He admitted bouncing checks to Butterfly Printers, which produced an attack mailer supporting Thao's mayoral campaign. [S1]
- He acknowledged knowingly issuing a bad check to cover the cost of negative campaign mailers. [S3]
- He admitted surrendering his real estate license after inflating a tenant's security deposit, and he said his actions were illegal. [S1][S3]
- He admitted keeping a woman's $44,000 check that should have been used to pay off her home loan. [S1]
The defense also questioned the plea deal itself, noting that Juarez was charged with one count of conspiracy while his alleged co-conspirators face several charges. [S3] It challenged his shifting account of where Thao was when she allegedly requested a $300,000 bribe for Jones. [S3]
The reports differ on timing. ABC7 places the cross-examination on Thursday, while KTVU says it came Friday on his first full day of cross-examination. [S1][S2]
PUBLIC OPINION
The only outside voice in these sources is Wilson Leung, a former federal corruption prosecutor quoted by ABC7. He said defense attorneys often seek to undermine a witness's credibility "even when they cannot expose a major contradiction." [S1]
Leung did not go easy on the witness. "Yes, Mr. Juarez has a lot of issues," he said, adding that Juarez has "admitted to crimes of his own, both related to the charged crimes and also past misconduct." [S1] That is a fair read of the record, and it is also a former prosecutor describing what the defense is doing, not predicting an acquittal. [S1]
BULLSHIT DEFENSE
No response from Thao appears in these sources.
The pushback in the reporting comes from lawyers for the Duongs, and it is the best version of the defense so far. Ed Swanson, an attorney for David Duong, spent hours attacking Juarez's honesty. [S2][S1] The defense argued that a $75,000 check from the Duong family's business was for legitimate work. [S3] It got Juarez to admit he threatened to pull his cooperation in emails that lost attorney-client privilege after he forwarded them to a friend. [S3] It played a recording in which Juarez described his frustration with Thao. [S1] In it he said "I think I was disappointed that she promised something and she is not keeping it." [S1]
That is a real argument. A witness with a grudge, a plea deal and a history of keeping other people's money gives a jury a reason to doubt him.
Here is why it does not carry the day for me. Juarez called the legitimate-work claim "laughable." [S3] He told the court he "pled to the crime I was guilty of," and when Swanson suggested he could be lying, Juarez answered that a lie would put his deal at risk. [S3][S2] And the recording the defense chose to play has him complaining that a promise was broken. That is a damn odd thing to say about a deal that never existed. Being a mess does not make a man a liar, and in my opinion crooks tend to recruit other crooks. A jury will decide, and Thao has not been convicted of anything.
Somebody in this story is lying to a federal court, and the f**king stakes are a mayor's office and millions of dollars in city business. The jury has to pick which version of Juarez to believe.
P.S. If the defense's whole case is that the people who talk to prosecutors are rarely saints, they have proven their point and still left the question unanswered.
Sources — 4 articles
Reported independently by 4 separate outlets. No single newsroom getting it wrong would put it here. Of those, 3 could be downloaded and read, and only those are cited below — the rest would not serve us the article. Every fact here was checked against text we actually hold.
- [S1] abc7news.com Defense attacks credibility of key witness Mario Juarez in trial of former Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao
- [S2] ktvu.com Key witness grilled in corruption trial of Oakland ex-mayor
- [S3] nbcbayarea.com Defense grills prosecution's central witness in Sheng Thao corruption trial
- [S4] cornell.edu 18 U.S.C. § 201(b) — Bribery of public officials