New Haven's Police Chief Gambled Away the Informant Fund, Then Said Sorry
Karl Jacobson, New Haven's former police chief, pleaded no contest to embezzling tens of thousands from a confidential informant fund and a youth league account to cover sports-betting losses.
Karl Jacobson — Former Police Chief of New Haven, Connecticut (Connecticut)
pleaded no contest to embezzlement chargesKarl Jacobson ran the New Haven Police Department for three years. He also spent part of that time moving the department's confidential informant fund and its youth league account into his DraftKings and FanDuel balances, and on Friday he pleaded no contest to embezzlement charges that make it official [S1].
The Case Against Karl Jacobson
A state police affidavit says Jacobson stole $81,500 from the police department's confidential informants fund and another $4,000 from the Police Activity League fund between January 1, 2024 and January 5, 2026 [S2][S3]. Bank records showed checks tied to that informant fund were deposited straight into Jacobson's personal checking account, and two PAL checks totaling $4,000 withdrawn on December 23 and 24, 2025 turned up in that same account [S3]. Investigators said no one else at the department was involved [S3]. His arrest warrant states that over about a year, between DraftKings and FanDuel, he wagered nearly $4.5 million, won about $ 4.2 million, and still came out $214,000 in the hole [S1]. He was arrested in February on two counts of Larceny in the First Degree by Defrauding a Public Community, released on a $150,000 bond, and on Friday pleaded no contest to embezzlement [S1][S2]. A restitution hearing is set for January 14, 2027 to fix how much is actually owed, and sentencing follows on January 29, 2027, with his own attorney saying he faces one to four years in prison [S1].
PUBLIC OPINION
New Haven Mayor Justin Elicker called the allegations "shocking" and a "betrayal of public trust" [S3]. Griffin, the chief state's attorney, said in a statement that "an allegation of embezzlement by a police official is a serious matter and potentially undermines public confidence in the criminal justice system" [S3].
BULLSHIT DEFENSE
Back in February, Jacobson's lawyer, Gregory Cerritelli, said he could not respond to the specific allegations yet but reminded the public that "an arrest is not evidence of guilt and allegations are not proof" [S3]. He added, "This is the beginning of a very long process," and said, " I urge everyone to keep an open mind and avoid a rush to judgment" [S3]. Fair enough, in February. By October, Jacobson stood outside the courthouse himself and said, "I apologize to the mayor and the city and the officers," adding, "I love the city. I hope the city moves forward. I hope the officers move forward, and that's all." [S1] That's not a denial. That's a man who ran out of road to deny anything on.
Jacobson had been with the department for 15 years before being named chief, and spent three of them as its boss, before burning through roughly $4.5 million in parlays on department time [S1][S3]. He told the assistant chiefs it wasn't that he was a bad person, just a problem he couldn't control [S2]. Maybe. The confidential informants who were supposed to get paid from that fund, and the kids in the Police Activity League, don't get an apology outside a courthouse. They get a restitution hearing.
P.S. That restitution hearing is set for January 14, 2027, and the number the state proves there will be the real measure of what actually came out of those two accounts [S1].
Sources — 3 articles
Reported independently by 3 separate outlets. No single newsroom getting it wrong would put it here.
- [S1] nbcconnecticut.com Former New Haven police chief pleads no contest in embezzlement case
- [S2] newhavenindependent.org Arrested Ex-Police Chief's Criminal Case Continued - New Haven Independent
- [S3] theguardian.com Former New Haven police chief charged with stealing $85,000 in agency funds